TLDR: Eight battery scientists wrote the most useful joke in the field: a peer-reviewed, straight-faced guide to making a mediocre result look like a miracle. Almost nobody pulls these tricks on purpose. Every one of them still works on you. Here are all ten, and the single question that calls each bluff.

Everyone can smell a battery press release that is too good to be true. Almost nobody can say exactly why. In 2021, Patrik Johansson and seven colleagues at Chalmers fixed that, publishing "Ten Ways to Fool the Masses When Presenting Battery Research" in Batteries & Supercaps, a deadpan homage to David Bailey's 1991 supercomputing classic. It reads like satire because it is. It is also the best BS detector in electrochemistry.

Their thesis, and mine: this is almost never fraud. It is the slow drift of a tired researcher at dusk, pressed to publish, reaching for the flattering plot. The tricks work regardless of intent, so the tells work regardless too.

Let's get into it.

BATTERY STOCKS: WEEK OF AUG 25 TO SEP 1, 2026
Data: Yahoo Finance as of Tuesday close
MATERIALS & RECYCLING
ABATAmerican Battery Technology Co ▲ 0.00%
$2.59 YTD -22.46%
ALBAlbemarle ▲ 1.77%
$135.54 YTD -4.17%
EVs & STORAGE
FLNCFluence Energy ▼ 7.30%
$10.42 YTD -47.32%
TSLATesla ▲ 1.67%
$356.09 YTD -20.82%
BATTERY CELLS
ENVXEnovix ▼ 0.89%
$3.35 YTD -54.17%
FACFactorial Energy ▼ 8.64%
$4.76 YTD -53.76%
QSQuantumScape ▼ 6.01%
$5.47 YTD -47.50%
SESAI ▼ 4.04%
$0.52 YTD -70.94%
SLDPSolid Power ▼ 0.43%
$2.33 YTD -45.18%

The ten (their trick, your tell)

1. Benchmark against 2010. The move: compare your result to a decade-old state of the art, because nothing has really happened in batteries since lithium-ion, right? Suddenly you are revolutionary. The tell: check the newest reference in the paper. If the baseline is ten years stale, the improvement is a race against a ghost.

2. Quote energy density from the chemistry, not the cell. The move: report the theoretical number straight from the reaction (gorgeous for Li-air and Li-S), and never mention that real electrodes also carry electrolyte, separator, current collectors, and a can. Let readers assume the coin-cell figure is what lands in their EV. The tell: ask what is in the denominator. Reaction energy and cell-level energy are different sports.

3. Price it by raw materials only. The move: quote cost as kilo-batch Sigma-Aldrich prices and call it almost free, while skipping the 8-step synthesis at 1200 C, the 2% yield, the single cell that survived, and the patent you filed. Bonus points for waving at earth-abundant metals that make up 1% of the electrode. The tell: ask how it is made and at what scale. Cheap precursors are not a cheap product.

4. Cherry-pick the cycling conditions. The move: got self-discharge or side reactions? Run high C-rates over a narrow state-of-charge window. Then quietly borrow the energy density from the full window, and now your cell has high power and high energy at once. Sluggish electrolyte? Run at C/20 and call it fundamental. The tell: watch the C-rate and the voltage window. If power and energy came from different runs, that is two cells wearing one costume.

5. Quietly change the setup mid-study. The move: a loading tweak here, an electrolyte swap there, none of it in the methods, all of it in a footnote to a table nobody reads. When someone cannot reproduce you, blame their conditions. The tell: read the SI and the fine print. Missing details are not sloppiness, they are the shield.

6. Play loadings and ratios. The move: use ultrathin electrodes packed with conductive carbon (great capacity per gram of active material, less electrolyte degradation, no mass-transport limits), then flood them with electrolyte so they cycle forever. Never report the loading or the electrolyte volume, so no one can calculate the charge actually transferred. The tell: ask for areal loading (mg/cm2 and mAh/cm2) and the electrolyte-to-active ratio. If they will not give you the numbers, that is the number.

7. Skip real characterization, or drown it in one exotic technique. The move: show an as-synthesized XRD, a handful of cycles, and stop. No post-cycling, no operando, what could possibly happen? Or flip it: run one $100,000 measurement no one else has, on a single cell, and let the price tag imply importance. The tell: ask what they measured after cycling, not just before. One fancy run on n=1 is a costume, not a control.

8. Everything is solid-state now. The move: chase the trend, announce record ionic conductivity, and never check whether it came from your material or leftover solvent. Add a little plasticizer and still call it solid, hiding behind quasi, semi, or hybrid. Just never say all, the ASSB old boys' club bites. The tell: watch for those prefixes and ask if anyone checked for residual solvent. A splash of liquid is not a solid electrolyte.

9. Errors? Not here. The move: cycle one heroic coin cell for three months and call it reproducible. Skip the error bars (we trust each other). Plot Coulombic efficiency on a 0-to-100% axis with a thick line, so no one sees it wobble erratically or peek above 100%. The tell: count the cells and look for the spread. n=1 is an anecdote, and a suspiciously smooth CE curve is a zoom level, not a result.

10. If all else fails, pretty pictures. The move: when the data underwhelm, reach for jewel-toned micrographs, tomography, a slick rocking-chair schematic, and an animation for socials. People pick papers by the table-of-contents image, after all. The tell: ask what the gorgeous figure actually proves. A cool render is not evidence.

The point. None of this makes the science fake. It makes the plot flattering, which is worse, because flattering survives peer review. The authors handed us the magician's manual on purpose. Learn the ten tells and the trick stops working. The masses get fooled. You read all the way down here, so you do not have to be one of them.

Some Resources We Love:

  • P. Johansson, S. Alvi, P. Ghorbanzade, M. Karlsmo, L. Loaiza, V. Thangavel, K. Westman, F. Årén, Batteries & Supercaps (2021). DOI: 10.1002/batt.202100154

  • Kang Xu, "Navigating the minefield of battery literature," Communications Materials (2022). DOI: 10.1038/s43246-022-00251-5

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Battery Burn Book to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now